Experts agree that the rare specimen is from Mongolia
His Excellency Elbegdorj Tsakhia, President of Mongolia, appointed a delegation to inspect the Tyrannosaurus bataar dinosaur that had been the subject of a May 20, 2012 auction by Heritage Auctions in New York City. The delegation included officials from Mongolia, Canada and the United States.
The inspection took place in the New York City area, on June 5, 2012, and proceeded with the full consent and assistance of Heritage Auctions and its consignor. The paleontologists who inspected the dinosaur, at the President’s request, included:
Philip Currie, MSc, PhD, FRSC
Professor and Canada Research Chair of Dinosaur Paleobiology at the University of
Alberta; and President of the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology
Tsogtbaatar Khishigjav, PhD
Head of Paleontological Laboratory and Museum, Mongolian Academy of Sciences
Bolor Minjin, PhD
Institute for the Study of Mongolian Dinosaurs
In addition, Mark Norell, PhD, Chairman and Curator, Division of Paleontology, at the American Museum of Natural History, New York, New York, collaborated in a report, based on his previous viewing of the dinosaur.
The paleontologists unanimously concluded that the specimen originated in Mongolia, based on unique characteristics of the Tyrannosaurus bataar. The paleontologists prepared reports, which are available for viewing via links at the bottom of this article. Dr. Currie and Dr. Norell wrote that, “The general appearance of the animal and the color of the bones indicate to us that this is the skull and skeleton of a Tarbosaurus bataar (also known as Tyrannosaurus bataar) from the Nemegt Formation of Mongolia.”
Indeed the auction catalog itself had described and publicized the specimen as a Tyrannosaurus bataar, so there has never been a dispute as to the species.
In addition to the paleontologists, the following non-scientific representatives attended the inspection:
Ann Altman, PhD
Advisor to President Elbegdorj on the Tyrannosaurus bataar issue
Baatar Choisuren
Minister/Counselor, Mongolian Embassy to the United States
Badruugan Naranzun
Director, Department of Culture and Art, Ministry of Education, Culture and Science of Mongolia
Robert Painter
Attorney for President Elbegdorj
Taunya Painter
Attorney for President Elbegdorj
Puntsag Tsagaan
Senior Advisor to President Elbegdorj
Attorney Robert Painter said, “President Elbegdorj’s staff has initiated thorough research into Mongolian law concerning the preservation of cultural treasures, like this Tyrannosaurus. We have concluded that Mongolian law has not permitted export of this rare fossil out of Mongolia since at least 1961. Nonetheless, we understand that significant value was added to the specimen by the consignor through initial identification, restoration and preparation. We are also grateful for the exemplary cooperation of Heritage Auctions, the contingent buyer and the consignor, without which this inspection could have been long and needlessly delayed. All parties remain hopeful that a fair and acceptable resolution can be reached without need for additional expert opinions or litigation.”
The Mongolian delegation is now traveling back to Ulaanbaatar. Upon their return to Mongolia and reporting to President Elbegdorj, the parties will continue discussions on how to resolve this important matter.
Additional Resources
Report by Dr. Philip Currie and Dr. Mark Norell
Report by Dr. Tsogtbaatar Khishigjav
Report by Dr. Bolor Minjin
Live Science coverage
Photo Caption
(L to R) Professor Philip Currie, PhD (President of the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology), Attorney Robert Painter, and Puntsag Tsagaan (Senior Advisor to the President of Mongolia) at the dinosaur inspection site.
News source :http://www.painterfirm.com/
Related articles
- Mongolian President and Heritage Auctions Cooperate on Investigation of Tyrannosaurus (prweb.com)
- Dinosaur skeleton sells for $1 million at New York auction (itv.com)
- Row dogs dinosaur skeleton sale (bbc.co.uk)
- Tyrannosaur Skeleton For Sale, But Ownership Is Questioned (livescience.com)
- T-Rex Wreck: Mongolian Representative Disrupts Skeleton Auction (observer.com)
- Tyrannosaur Skeleton For Sale, But Ownership Is Questioned (news.discovery.com)
- You: Tyrannosaurus skeleton to be auctioned in New York (guardian.co.uk)
- Tyrannosaur is Truly Mongolian, Experts Declare, Challenging Sale (livescience.com)
- U.S. auction house to help Mongolia trace dinosaur’s origin (reuters.com)
- Auctioned Tyrannosaur Skeleton Possibly Smuggled (livescience.com)
- Tyrannosaur is truly Mongolian, experts declare – Fox News (foxnews.com)
- Mongolia tries to stop sale of rare dinosaur fossil (cnn.com)
- Tarbosaurus vs. Tyrannosaurus: What’s the Difference? (livescience.com)
- Report: Tyrannosaur swiped from Mongolia (content.usatoday.com)
- How much does a Tyrannosaurus cost? About $1m, apparently (sociable.co)
- Rare tyrannosaurus skeleton to be auctioned (mnn.com)
- Dinosaur Dustup: Auctioneer, Mongolia Battle Over $1M Bones (undisputedlegal.wordpress.com)
- Tyrannosaur saved by the T.R.O. – for now (skepticblog.org)
- Stop the Tarbosaurus Auction! (wired.com)
- Disputed dinosaur fossil auctioned for $1M in NYC (sfgate.com)
- Tyrannosaurus Skeleton Goes On Auction Block (webpronews.com)
- Tyrannosaur auctioned despite protests from Mongolia (newscientist.com)
- Dino Dustup: Battle Over T-rex Cousin (abcnews.go.com)
- Disputed dinosaur fossil auctioned for $1M in NYC (cbsnews.com)
- Disputed dinosaur fossil auctioned for $1M in NYC (seattletimes.nwsource.com)
- Hey Rich People, Stop Buying Nature (motherboard.vice.com)
- Disputed dinosaur fossil auctioned for $1M in NYC (kansascity.com)
- Battle for $1 million dinosaur (rt.com)
- Mongolia wants its $1m T-Rex back (slashgear.com)
- Disputed dinosaur fossil auctioned in NYC – Zee News (zeenews.india.com)
- Disputed Fossil Auctioned Off for $1 MILLION Despite Court Order (blippitt.com)
- Dallas-Based Auction House Reaches Agreement In Dinosaur Dispute (dfw.cbslocal.com)
- Alt Text: Diary of a Dino-Smuggler (wired.com)
- Despite legal challenge, tyrannosaur sells for $1 million (news.yahoo.com)
- Tyrannosaur sells for $1 million — despite legal challenge (foxnews.com)
- Strange Bedrock Fellows: Auction House and Mongolian President to Cooperate in Fight Over Fossil (observer.com)
- Heritage Auctions is Being Sued by Mongolia — Yes, the Country — Over the Sale of a Dinosaur (blogs.dallasobserver.com)
- Dinosaur skeleton fetches $1.05 mln at disputed US auction (vancouversun.com)
- Dino might: Houston trial lawyer gets TRO to stop auction of dinosaur bones (texaslawyer.typepad.com)
- Tyrannosaurus sold for S$1.33 million amid question over ownership (todayonline.com)
- Dinosaur skeleton fetches $1.05 million at disputed US auction (vancouversun.com)
- Origin of skeleton to be auctioned questioned (refreshingnews99.blogspot.com)
- U.S. Auction House to Help Mongolia Trace Dinosaur’s Origin (scientificamerican.com)
I do hope your government will retain the rights to this important paleontological discovery. Thank you for reading my blog, Diane T. and furfamily
Tyrannosaurus will be home soon. American government law and customs helping to amke it happen.
about your blog.
i have dream about to publish my book.
might be in the near future. you would be my guide to accomplish my dream.
Byamba
Hi, thanks.
I have also blogged on this:
http://dearkitty1.wordpress.com/2012/05/21/tyrannosaurus-fossil-science-or-big-money/